Credibility Package PDF Print E-mail
Written by Mark Healey   
Monday, 13 October 2008
I don't think I can bring anything new to the whole “The Internet Is Changing The Way Sports Media Does Business” mantra, but I can tell you one thing, I seem to be working too hard.  Or it seems, not hard enough.  I mean, working the phones all day to get some juicy New York baseball stories during the World Series is obviously a waste of time, since some people can miraculous find a huge nugget under all of our very noses.  It must be because he's really in the know.  When most of us are speculating about what these teams are going to do, there are some guys out there that have enough moxie to get GMs and their cohorts to gab about their secret plans to outwit each other on the grandest of all baseball stages.






I mean, you'd have to be in the know to be able to get two of the most powerful GMs in baseball (who each got multi-year extensions despite not making the postseason, and having the largest payroll in their respective leagues), to tell you that they are talking trades before they've had their organizational meetings, or addressed their coaching staffs, or finished watching the damn playoffs, right?

***

Much like “J-RodGate” a few months ago, this Cano-Beltran thing -- and let's call it a fabrication, because that's exactly what it smells like --  was another transparent event by a aspiring “sports writer” to publicize an either long-dormant website or help an emerging blog get some recognition.  I mean, really, why else would anyone even think it was newsworthy, relevant or even remotely possible?

Other than the aforementioned “PR grab”, why else would you publish it? He's not actually working for a media outlet, nor is he a writer by trade.  I'm not aware that he's actually covering the people he claims to have these intimate conversations with, or has to look them in the eye and ask them questions at events like the Winter Meetings.  That may not mean much to you readers out there, but it means something to me.  I do this for a living, not a hobby.  People who think it's amusing to stir up an industry to prove some kind of elitist point, pain me. 

What is he risking by “giving” anyone this info?  The answer is nothing,  Therefor the intent, execution and end result (or Journalism 101) must not only be questioned, but castigated.  Why, you ask?  Because there are hundreds or hard-working online media guys like myself that die a little bit every time some guy with no affiliation, no credibility package and no accountability, floats one of these rumors, that's why.

We have a living to lose, he has a website's audience to win.  He doesn't have press credentials at stake, or clubhouse access to lose, and whenever any of us even attempts to bring objectivity to the table, those things are held above our heads.   Many of us report what we know anyway, even if it does create difficulty for us.  I really try true to what I do, and I'll be damned if I am going to sit back and watch some guy who I have never seen in a press box or press conference in my life, help to injure a medium which thousands of people are trying to make work.

***

First of all, the whole Mets-Yankees trade thing very rarely happens, and when it does, it is for a far cry less than Beltran-Cano.  The last time a rumor of this type came out is was a Gary Sheffield for Mike Cameron rumor, and even that got less mileage than  this gem.

Look, as long as teams are still working out their organizational meetings, determining their coaching staffs and addressing internal decisions, GMs have little time (or desire) to talk about trades, especially complicated trades with crosstown rivals that have serious potential to blow up in their collective faces if it gos wring either way.  Kind of stinks when reality enters the picture, doesn't it?

Also,  Omar Minaya and Brian Cashman are quite friendly, and would not require any the usual Asst. GM-Asst. GM preliminary sit-downs, which is where most of the trade rumor stuff gets leaked – usually as a negotiating tool”.  There's very, very little of this going on right now.  

Except in a select few corners of reality, it seems.
Last Updated ( Monday, 13 October 2008 )
 
< Prev   Next >

GOTHAM SPORTS MEDIA NETWORK



Gotham Sponsor

Who's Online

Gotham Sponsor

© 2009 Online Home of Gotham Baseball Magazine
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.